Rykelan Brown, 4, had foster parents who loved him.
But Cortland County social services forced him to live with his biological father in DeWitt. The dad, Joshua Emmons, beat him to death in March 2024.
Nearly everyone wrestled with those truths in a small courtroom Tuesday in Syracuse as Rykelan’s killer — his own father, who had a history of abusive behavior — was sentenced to 25 years in prison for manslaughter.
“The truth is, we fought so hard to keep him safe,” foster mom Sam Adams said at Emmons’ sentencing. “It’s unbearable to think that he felt, for even one second, that he was unlovable or unwanted.”
Related article: ‘Daddy Josh hit me’: Child welfare workers ignored red flags and sent a boy to his death
Emmons, 27, of DeWitt, beat the preschooler so badly his brain bled. Emmons, who had pleaded guilty in August, showed no emotion during the half-hour sentencing and said nothing when given the chance.
In an interview with authorities before sentencing, Emmons offered no apologies for the beating, saying only that he’d been drinking alcohol the day he took his little boy’s life, the judge noted.
“No apology, no remorse, just some lame excuse for killing your son,” Judge Mary Anne Doherty said.
That leaves Rykelan’s foster parents and his biological mother, McKenzie Brown, with questions that have no answers.
“His father, who should have loved him, took his life,” McKenzie Brown said in court, adding later that 25 years was too short a punishment for Emmons.
Rykelan had lived with his foster parents, Sam and Theo Adams, so long they couldn’t imagine life without him.
“We expected and wanted him to become a permanent member of our family,” Sam Adams said. “He made me a mother, and I loved him fiercely.”
She watched Rykelan grow from a baby to an inquisitive preschooler who traded a sippy cup for a prized dinosaur, a collection of diggers for a pile of books.
Then, in 2024, Rykelan was taken from the love and stability of his Cortland County foster home to a strange house in DeWitt filled with seven other children he’d never met and an abusive father who ended up beating him to death.
Why did a father seek custody of his son, only to kill him two months later? And how was he allowed to do that?
A syracuse.com | The Post-Standard investigation found that the foster parents raised concerns over and over that were not taken seriously. Instead, emails, text messages, videos, social service records and court reports show that Cortland County caseworkers seemed driven to close Rykelan’s case. They dismissed reports of physical abuse, eventually green-lighting Emmons’s home, despite the fact that it was a dangerous mess.
Cortland County DSS Commissioner Kristen Monroe has refused to answer questions from syracuse.com. The Adams are in the process of suing Cortland County for failing to protect Rykelan.
Rykelan’s foster mom made sure to reference some of the missteps Tuesday in court.
“I won’t detail the emotional challenges and red flags that appeared between September of 2023, when Emmons’ first filed for custody, and March 2024, when the courts granted that request,” Sam Adams told a judge. “This sentencing isn’t about the custody process. It isn’t about Emmons assuring us that my husband and I could maintain an active role in Rykelan’s life... It isn’t even about the last text message I sent Emmons, where I asked him to wish Rykelan a happy birthday, unaware of what was happening behind closed doors.
“This is about a little boy who was taken from a home where he would be cherished,” Sam Adams said.
Judge Doherty wrestled with the same questions before pronouncing the agreed-upon 25-year sentence.
“I cannot understand what kind of monster seeks custody of his child, only to inflict such serious injuries on a 4-year-old boy to cause his death,” Doherty told Emmons. “You should have left Rykelan with his foster parents... It was, by all accounts, the only place he felt love, or was loved, a place he was clearly cared for.”